Bedpan Washer vs Macerator: Which is best for you?

Bedpan Washer-Disinfectors vs Pulp Macerators: How to Choose for Your Care Home?

Choosing the right sluice room equipment isn’t just about convenience, it’s about safeguarding residents, supporting staff, and managing costs. Across UK care homes, there’s a noticeable shift in sluice room practice. Where bedpan washer-disinfectors (BPWs) once dominated, pulp macerators are increasingly becoming the preferred choice. Both bedpan washers and pulp macerators have clear benefits, and the right choice depends on your care home’s infection control goals, budget, staffing, and environmental priorities.

Infection Control: Disposable vs Reusable 

• Macerators seen by many IPC practitioners as the gold standard, use single-use pulp containers, which are placed in the machine and disposed into the waste system. This removes the risk of cross-contamination from reused items. Many models also feature hands-free operation and antimicrobial surfaces, supporting good hygiene.
• Bedpan washers include an integrated slop hopper to dispose of waste.  The machine then cleans and thermally disinfects reusable bedpans, commode pots, and urine bottles at >80°C. They also feature hands-free loading and antimicrobial technology, supporting good hygiene.

Running Costs and Consumables

• Macerators consume less energy and water per cycle than bedpan washers, however, they require a regular supply of pulp containers.  While this adds to ongoing operating costs, the system can save staff time, reduce the risk of HCAI’s and prevent issues from manual cleaning.
• Bedpan washers consume more water and energy per cycle but don’t rely on disposable supplies, however, they require a regular supply of chemicals to support effective operation. Reusable bedpans do need periodic replacement, which should be factored into long-term costs.

Environmental Considerations

• Macerators pulp containers are biodegradable, breaking down safely in the sewage system. However, they do rely on single-use items, which some care homes view as less sustainable than reusing containers. The key consideration is whether lower utility use outweighs concerns about disposables.
• Bedpan washers reduce solid waste by reusing containers, which may suit homes aiming to cut back on disposables. The trade-off is higher water and energy consumption, which carries both environmental and financial implications. Care homes may need to decide which factor – waste or utility use – has the greater impact.

 Space and Installation 

• Macerators need plumbing and dedicated sluice room space. They are available in different sizes, with compact models that can be fitted easily and larger options that provide higher capacity where demand is greater.
• Bedpan washers also require plumbing and sluice room space. Most models are broadly similar in size, though capacity can vary. They are generally straightforward to install, provided the sluice room layout is suitable.
  
  

How to Decide Between a Bedpan Washer and a Macerator

When planning your sluice room setup, consider:

1. Infection prevention goals – Do you want to prioritise single-use solutions to minimise cross-contamination risk?
2. What is your preferred method of waste disposal – single use pulp items, or plastic reusable items?
3. Usage levels – How many bedpans or containers are used daily, and can your equipment handle the demand?
4. Available space – Is there room for a larger bedpan washer, or is a compact macerator more practical?
5. Costs – Look beyond the upfront purchase to consider consumables, utilities, maintenance, and staff time.
6. Sustainability – Is reducing waste or lowering water and energy use a higher priority for your care group?

Many care homes find that a hybrid strategy offers the best results:

• Macerators: For high-risk patients or areas where infection prevention is the top priority.
• Bedpan washers: For routine use where reusable containers are practical and cost-effective.

There’s no single answer that suits every care home. Both macerators and bedpan washer-disinfectors have clear benefits and practical challenges. By considering infection control, efficiency, costs, and environmental impact, care groups can make a decision that protects residents, supports staff, and fits their wider operational goals.

Get in touch with a member of our team to arrange an assessment or audit, and we’ll provide tailored guidance to help you choose the right solution for your care home.

More Information

Find out more about DDC's Hospital Sluice Room Management solution.